Why the most debated concept in fitness is both true and useless at the same time
The Paradox
Yes, thermodynamics applies to humans. Energy cannot be created or destroyed. If you consistently consume less energy than you expend, you will lose mass. This is physics. It's non-negotiable.
But here's what the "CICO" slogan misses: the human body is not a bomb calorimeter. The "calorie" printed on a label was calculated by burning food in a 19th-century furnace. Your gut — with its 38 trillion bacteria, enzyme variations, and inflammatory status — extracts a wildly different amount of usable energy from that same food.
Two people can eat identical meals, train identically, and get completely different results — not because physics broke, but because their bodies made different regulatory decisions about what to do with that energy.
The Real Question
The debate isn't whether energy balance exists. It does.
The question is: What determines how your body regulates that balance?
The question is: What determines how your body regulates that balance?
The answer is a symphony of signals:
• Thyroid hormones deciding your metabolic set point
• Leptin and ghrelin influencing hunger and satiety
• Cortisol determining energy storage vs. release
• Inflammatory cytokines shifting fuel partitioning
• Mitochondrial uncoupling proteins generating heat instead of ATP
• Muscle-secreted myokines instructing fat cells to mobilize or hold
• Your nervous system interpreting safety vs. scarcity
• Thyroid hormones deciding your metabolic set point
• Leptin and ghrelin influencing hunger and satiety
• Cortisol determining energy storage vs. release
• Inflammatory cytokines shifting fuel partitioning
• Mitochondrial uncoupling proteins generating heat instead of ATP
• Muscle-secreted myokines instructing fat cells to mobilize or hold
• Your nervous system interpreting safety vs. scarcity
Energy balance is real. But it's not a dial you control directly. It's an emergent property of a massively complex regulatory system responding to biological signals, psychological stress, sleep quality, gut health, and identity coherence.
The Synthesis ↓
CICO isn't wrong — it's just the outcome, not the mechanism.
Fat loss doesn't happen because you "burned more than you ate."
It happens because your body permitted fat oxidation when the system felt safe, aligned, and coherent.
Fat loss doesn't happen because you "burned more than you ate."
It happens because your body permitted fat oxidation when the system felt safe, aligned, and coherent.
This is why two diets with identical calorie counts produce different results. Why stress tanks progress. Why sleep matters more than an extra workout. Why rigid tracking works for some and destroys others.
The body doesn't passively account for energy.
It actively decides what to do with it.
It actively decides what to do with it.
No comments:
Post a Comment